New Model Y braking failure and crashes
In recent weeks, we compiled the common problems encountered with the new Tesla Model Y in the three months since its launch and noted that the most critical issues stem from the vehicle’s braking system. Since then, crashes caused by the car failing to stop despite the driver pressing the brake pedal—and near-miss incidents of the same nature—have emerged on social media:
In addition to these, there is another crash video that was shared with me but cannot be published due to the lack of permission from the vehicle owner. Other users who narrowly avoided crashing into the car in front and complained about the brake pedal include:
In most of these cases, users report that despite pressing the brakes firmly, the car did not slow down as expected, and they describe a sensation of the vehicle “slipping away from under them.” One car owner described their experience as follows:
- Speed is generally around 60 km/h.
- The road incline is close to zero, with some examples on a slight downhill slope.
- All vehicles had less than 80% charge, meaning the battery wasn't full and regenerative braking should still have been active.
- In some cases, regenerative braking was set to “low,” and in others, to “high.”
- Even in cases where regenerative braking was set to “high,” no significant deceleration was observed during the few seconds between releasing the accelerator and pressing the brake.
- In examples with Autopilot engaged, Adaptive Cruise Control and Automatic Emergency Braking deactivate 4–5 seconds before the crash (SNA = signal not available).
- Although the data shows ABS is triggered at the moment the brake is pressed, none of the users report feeling any vibration in the brake pedal.
In reality, Juniper’s brakes are more than adequate; in user tests, stopping distances from 100 km/h range between 36–38 meters. The issue seems to stem more from the calibration of the electric brake system used in the new generation Model Y, and from flaws in the functioning of the vehicle’s ADAS (Advanced Driver Assistance Systems).
Let’s hear directly from Lars Moravy, Tesla’s VP of Vehicle Engineering, about how this braking system—referred to as “hydraulic-by-wire” and described as a transition toward brake-by-wire—works:
“We still have hydraulic brakes, but brake actuation is entirely done by an electric motor on the servo side. The brake pedal is connected to a sensor that detects movement, and this signal is sent to the motor. Of course, there’s also a hydraulic backup system, because in a ‘go-stop-turn’ scenario, while losing steering might not be as bad, being able to stop is very important. In this first attempt, we wanted to be very cautious and retain the ability to brake via a hydraulic bypass over the motor.
This system gives us two advantages: First, we can make the brake pedal feel very consistent. For example, we can add as much regenerative braking as we want to the A pedal (accelerator). If the weather is cold or you're new to EVs and prefer low regen, we can transfer that braking to the B pedal (brake) and still achieve the same deceleration. That allows us to recover all the energy. This results in a 0.25% to 0.5% efficiency gain.
Another important point is that, since we no longer rely on the hydraulic system’s stiffness for pedal feel—thanks to the electric motor in the brake servo making the system independent from hydraulics—we can pull the brake pads back a bit more than usual. That means less drag. But because braking now happens through the motor, we can push the pads back to the disc very quickly, maintaining a strong bite feel. The feedback drivers get from the pedal is now entirely controlled by our mechanical system and no longer tied to hydraulics.”
We had previously given examples showing how clumsy Autopilot operates in the new Model Y and how this indirectly encourages customers to purchase the more sophisticated FSD (Full Self-Driving) package. Tesla, a brand that relies on cameras instead of radars (LiDAR) for autonomous driving, frequently faces criticism for this decision—and many “autonomous crashes” are attributed to it.
The system, which should normally slow down along with the vehicle in front, continues traveling at a constant speed during crashes, relinquishing control to the driver without any warning. In these moments—when the gap has already closed dangerously—the collision avoidance system either fails to activate or only kicks in when it’s already too late.
Tesla states in its documentation that Autopilot should not be fully relied upon, that an error margin must be maintained, and that drivers must always stay alert. But this calls into question why such systems are installed at all—especially when, not just in Teslas but in many other cars I’ve tested with adaptive cruise control, they repeatedly make critical errors that endanger both the driver and those around them.

10 Comments