How reliable is Euro NCAP?
Questioning the reliability of an organisation that has been conducting crash tests for 29 years and is used as a reference on car safety by almost everyone may sound odd at first. That is not exactly what I am trying to do, either; my aim is rather to draw attention to some contradictions in certain Euro NCAP results, to shed light on the inconsistencies behind the scores awarded, and to encourage us to take such an important issue as safety more seriously.
A few months ago, in my article titled “Crash test guide and the most dangerous cars”, I touched on this topic. This time I am expanding and diversifying the examples I used there:
- Renault Zoe, which scored 5 stars in 2013, received 0 stars in 2021.
- Ford Puma, which scored 5 stars in 2019, received 4 stars in 2022.
- Volkswagen T-Cross, which scored 5 stars in 2019, received 3 stars in 2025.
Question: How can we know whether a car we buy today on the basis of its Euro NCAP result will still be considered “safe” a few years from now?
2 . In 2009 the organisation also began to assess active safety systems such as autonomous emergency braking and adaptive cruise control, and since then the weight of these systems in the criteria has steadily increased. For example, if you look at the individual categories of the Renault Duster test, driver/adult occupant protection is 4 stars and child occupant protection is 5 stars; however, because of a 57% score for driver assistance systems, the overall result is 3 stars.
Question: For a driver whose first act upon getting into the car is to switch off the driver assistance systems because of their annoying and unnecessary warnings, is a car like the Duster really “unsafe”?
3 . The BYD Atto 3 left its first test in 2022 with 5 stars. However, at that time the organisation was only assessing the presence of driver assistance systems, not how they actually worked. The same model returned to Euro NCAP in 2024, and because its adaptive cruise control caused an accident, it was rated as “not recommended”.
Question: Under General Safety Requirements 2 (GSR2), all vehicles registered after 7 July 2024 and sold in European Union countries must offer basic driver assistance systems as standard equipment; many consumers base their choice on this and therefore avoid buying pre-2024 cars. But how many of these customers actually know whether the driver assistance systems in the car they are buying work properly?
4 . In some cases there are differences in standard equipment between the version of a car tested by Euro NCAP and the version sold in Turkey. Take the Renault Clio, for example: the test result is 5 stars, but unlike the car in the test, none of the Clio 5s sold in Turkey has curtain airbags. Two of the organisation’s six main tests assess side impacts, and in both of them the curtain airbags deploy.
Question: How many stars would a Clio 5 sold in Turkey receive if it were tested?
5 . In the 2025 T-Cross crash test video, at 0:53, footage of the 2019 model is shown.
Question: Was a 2019 car used in the 2025 model’s test because there has been no change in the side impact test procedure? If so, why does the current model appear in the other side-impact shots in the same video?
6 . In the 2022 Taigo crash test video, a Polo was used in all tests except the frontal impact because, in the organisation’s own words, it is “structurally the same vehicle”.
Question: If we can assume that the results of cars built on the same underpinnings are identical, why does the previous-generation Peugeot 3008 have 5 stars, while the essentially same vehicle, the Citroën C5 Aircross, has 4 stars?
7 . In last month’s test of the Chery Tiggo 8, the Tiggo 7 was again used for the same reason. In the side barrier test in July, the Tiggo 7’s curtain airbag came off its rail and failed to protect the head of the child dummy, and the car received 4 stars. Euro NCAP gave Chery the chance to correct the production defect and, in the re-assessment in October 2025, again using a Tiggo 7, this time awarded the Tiggo 8 5 stars.
Question: How many Chery Tiggo 8 owners are aware of this safety weakness in cars produced before July 2025?
8 . In the MG 3 test conducted last September, during the 50 km/h frontal offset crash, the driver’s seat detached from its mounting. This was the first time such an event had ever occurred in the organisation’s history, yet Euro NCAP still awarded the MG 3 a 74% adult-occupant protection score and an overall 4-star rating. Although the organisation published the relevant report on its website, it did not include this footage in the crash-test video.
Question: How can we trust an safety organisation that gives a car four out of five stars even though its seat broke off during the crash?
9 . Although the Peugeot 2008 received 4–5 stars from Euro NCAP, it was awarded only 1 star by Latin NCAP, the same organization’s South American counterpart, due to structural weaknesses at the front and the absence of curtain airbags.
Question: Should safety depend on where you buy it?

14 Comments