Most reliable cars under 5.000.000TL
We continue to rank cars that won’t leave you stranded, give you headaches, or burn a hole in your pocket. Our Most Reliable Cars series covers different price ranges, and in each installment I recommend three cars. I also try to make sure these recommendations offer some variety in terms of segment, body style, or overall character. If several cars in the same segment offer a similar level of reliability, I choose the one that delivers better value for money and offers qualities beyond reliability itself, such as comfort, refinement, sound insulation, handling, and so on.
Audi A6 (2018–2025)
Segment: E-segment sedan/station wagon
Engines: 2.0-liter turbocharged mild-hybrid petrol 45 TFSI (245 hp in 2019–2020, 265 hp thereafter); 163 hp 2.0-liter mild-hybrid diesel 35 TDI; 204 hp 2.0-liter mild-hybrid diesel 40 TDI; 286 hp 3.0-liter mild-hybrid diesel 50 TDI. 35 TDI models are front-wheel drive, while 40 TDI models can be either front-wheel drive or quattro. The others are available only with quattro. My recommendation: 45 TFSI. Note: The mild-hybrid system in the 2.0-liter versions is 12V and the all-wheel-drive system is Quattro Ultra. The 3.0-liter versions use a 48V mild-hybrid system and a Torsen-based permanent Quattro system.
Equipment: Desirable features include HD Matrix LED headlights, adaptive cruise control, a 360° camera, Bang & Olufsen audio, soft-close doors, and acoustic glass. Rarer options include RS seats, ventilated seats, head-up display, air suspension, rear-wheel steering, and the Night Vision system. The 2024 facelift brought a new grille, bumpers, and wheel designs; Virtual Cockpit and the more advanced Parking Assist Plus became standard.
Watch out for: Quattro Ultra vibration/binding issues. Oil loss in the DL382 transmission. AdBlue, DPF, and EGR issues on diesels. BSG/alternator failures in the 48V mild-hybrid system on 50 TDI models.
Porsche Macan (2014–2024)
Segment: D-segment SUV
Engines: 2.0-liter turbocharged petrol EA888: 237 hp until 2016, 252 hp between 2016 and 2019, 245 hp between 2019 and 2022, and 265 hp from 2022 onward. Up to 2022, these used the Evo3 version with an IHI turbocharger; from 2022 onward, the Evo4 version was paired with a BorgWarner turbo. The rarer Turbo version was produced until 2018 and used a 400 hp twin-turbo 3.6-liter V6. My recommendation: 2019 and newer.
Automatic transmission: 7-speed wet dual-clutch DL501.
Equipment: Desirable options include a panoramic opening glass roof, Sport Chrono, PASM/air suspension, 14- or 18-way memory seats, ventilated seats, sports exhaust, BOSE audio, and a 360° camera. Early Macans used PCM 3, with a low-resolution center display and a thick bezel. From 2016 onward, PCM 4 and CarPlay were introduced. The first facelift in 2019 brought the wide-screen PCM 5 system; the second facelift in 2022 made adaptive LED headlights, a touch-sensitive center console, and an analog clock standard. Note that the presence of this clock on top of the dashboard alone does not mean the car has the Sport Chrono package; it should also have the Sport Plus driving mode.
Watch out for: Transfer-case failures in cars built before March 2018. Clutch replacement on the DL501 at around 100,000 km. Failure of exhaust flaps/valves.
BMW 4 Series (2020–)
Segment: D-segment coupe/four-door coupe/convertible
Engines: 170 hp 1.6-liter turbocharged petrol (B48) 420i; 252 hp 2.0-liter turbocharged petrol (B48) 430i; 190 hp 2.0-liter diesel (B47) 420d. The 420d and 430i can also be had with xDrive all-wheel drive. The G23 convertible, meanwhile, was sold only as a 430i. My recommendation: 2024 and newer (LCI) 420i.
Automatic transmission: 8-speed torque-converter ZF 8HP.
Equipment: The Coupe (G22) and Gran Coupe (G26) were sold in M Sport/Edition M Sport trim, with a sunroof, electrically adjustable memory front seats with heating, keyless entry, wireless charging, driver-assistance systems, and Harman Kardon audio as standard. A 360° camera, M4 seats, laser headlights, and a head-up display were optional. In March 2023, before the facelift, the infotainment system moved from iDrive 7 to iDrive 8, bringing a standard 12.3-inch instrument display and 14.9-inch central screen. The 2024 LCI introduced iDrive 8.5, redesigned headlights and taillights, and an updated interior.
Watch out for: Coolant leaks from the radiator, water pump, and hoses on B48 engines. Differential whine. Side mirrors that occasionally fail to fold or unfold.

2 Comments